Friday, 24 June 2011

Sonic Generations demo impressions.

So, it's officially Sonic the Hedgehog's 20th anniversary, and I thought I'd celebrate it by talking about the Sonic Generations demo. However, it wasn't exactly what I expected.

It's no secret I am a huge Sonic fan. I have the games, T-Shirts, Toys, soundtracks. Sonic was a large portion of my life back during their 15th anniversary and, despite the undeniable decline of quality in the games, I have maintained my love for e blue rodent. So naturally, the Sonic Generations demo drew me in instantly.

For this who are out of the loop, Generations is a tribute to the Sonic world. It presents some of the greatest levels from the back-catalogue of games in glorious HD or 3D, and allows you to play as both side scrolling Classic Sonic, or the newer 3 dimensional Modern Sonic. Sonic Team have lovingly crafted the levels and translated them into both Sonic gameplay styles.

The demo takes you on a journey of arguably the most iconic Sonic level; Green Hill Zone. Immediately I noticed that, while the graphics are stunning HD renditions of the classic level, the level design was roughly unchanged. This instantly set my expectations very high.

However, the level held a constant style-over-function feel until the short level ended and the demo cut to black. The levels seemed too detailed and drew attention away from Sonic, and the camera couldn't stay still, swaying around to showcase the HD graphics.

Moreover, the Classic Sonic feels like playing a Sonic Advance title. If the recent Sonic 4 is anything to go by, it's that speed is not always best, and Generations fell straight into the trap of going too quickly, and posing little challenge as long as you held right on the controller. Sonic Team also decided on assigning Spin Dash its own button, which is not only stupid but ended up acting more like a constant boost. The usual means of Spin Dash felt fine, but the X version (or square on PS3 I assume) was an instant full-speed boost. This was also required multiple times to break rocks in a quick-time-event style break up of gameplay.

I'd talk about Modern Sonic, but we weren't given that on the demo. Shady.

This got me thinking. Is this really how we should remember Sonic? The first 3 games weren't this fast, were nowhere near as beautiful, but played so much better than Generations. I'd sooner play Green Hill Zone 30,000 times on the Megadrive than play the remake on Generations, and that isn't because of nostalgia goggles. If I'm honest, I was more excited to play City Escape from Sonic Adventure 2, but I don't know if the game is worth buying to see them remake that in HD.

You see, Sonic HAS been in a decline. Their 15th anniversary game was a shambles, and their collective fan base is so indecisive about what they want that Sonic Team have started handing anything they ask for on silver platters. Sonic has reached 20 years, but I can't honestly see hum stumbling through another 20. However, Sonic will never die because, if he does, he'll most likely take SEGA with him. So, like it or not, Sonci is here to stay.

Happy 20th, Sonic. I'm going to play Sonic 2 and Adventure 2 again. I'll remember you how I should.

No comments:

Post a Comment